Abstract
Purpose
The purpose of this study is to determine the effectiveness of HLA typing in preventing corneal allograft rejection.
Methods
This retrospective single-center study analyzed 459 consecutive HLA-typed patients who underwent perforating keratoplasty (PKP) between 1983 and 2001. Grafts were postoperatively transparent after donor-recipient selection by HLA-A, -B and -DR typing. Patients were divided into a low- and a high-risk group based on their preoperative diagnosis.
Results
The estimated 1-, 5- and 10-year graft survival (Kaplan-Meier) was 93, 88 and 67% in low-risk patients and 73, 43 and 38% in high-risk patients. We found a significant correlation between the number of HLA mismatches and the rate of allograft rejections: a donor-recipient match of two or more alleles in HLA-A, -B or -DR reduces the rejection rate by at least 10% in low-risk (10 years after PKP; P<0.04) and 40% in high-risk patients (3 years after PKP; P<0.0001). Especially HLA-B mismatches are important prognostic factors for both low- (P<0.008) and high-risk patients (P<0.003). Considering both HLA-B and -DR mismatches significantly reduces the rate of allograft rejection, particularly in high-risk patients (P<0.0001). Matching on a split typing level offers no significant advantage over broad level matching.
Conclusion
Clinical results confirm theories developed to explain the function of the HLA (MHC) receptor. The closest possible donor-recipient match of HLA antigens based on broad level typing significantly reduces the rate of allograft rejection and thus improves the prognosis for long-term transparency of corneal grafts in both high- and low-risk patients.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Baggesen K, Ehlers N, Lamm LU (1991) HLA-DR/RFLP compatible corneal grafts. Acta Ophthalmol (Copenhagen) 69:229–233
Baggesen K, Lamm LU, Ehlers N (1996) Significant effect of high-resolution HLA-DRB1 matching in high-risk corneal transplantation. Transplantation 62:1273–1277
Bartels MC, Otten HG, van Gelderen BE, Van der Lelij A (2001) Influence of HLA-A, HLA-B, and HLA-DR matching on rejection of random corneal grafts using corneal tissue for retrospective DNA HLA typing. Br J Ophthalmol 85:1341–1346
Beekhuis WH, Bartels M, Doxiadis, II, van Rij G (2003) Degree of compatibility for HLA-A and -B affects outcome in high-risk corneal transplantation. Dev Ophthalmol 36:12–21
Bohringer D, Reinhard T, Bohringer S, Enczmann J, Godehard E, Sundmacher R (2002) Predicting time on the waiting list for HLA matched corneal grafts. Tissue Antigens 59:407–411
Boisjoly HM, Roy R, Dube I, Laughrea PA, Michaud R, Douville P, Heebert J (1986) HLA-A,B and DR matching in corneal transplantation. Ophthalmology 93:1290–1297
Bradley BA, Vail A, Gore SM, Rogers CA, Armitage WJ, Nicholls S, Easty DL (1995) Negative effect of HLA-DR matching on corneal transplant rejection. Transplant Proc 27:1392–1394
Claas FHJ, Roelen DL, D'Amaro J, Völker-Dieben HJ (1994) The role of HLA in corneal transplantation. In: Zierhut M (ed) Immunology of corneal transplantation. Aeolus Press Scientific Publishers, Buren, The Netherlands, p 47
Collaborative Corneal Transplantation Studies Research Group(1992) The collaborative corneal transplantation studies (CCTS). Effectiveness of histocompatibility matching in high-risk corneal transplantation. Arch Ophthalmol 110:1392–1403
Creemers PC, Kahn D, Hill JC (1999) HLA-A and -B alleles in cornea donors as risk factors for graft rejection. Transplant Immunol 7:15–18
Dikstein S, Maurice DM (1972) The metabolic basis to the fluid pump in the cornea. J Physiol 221:29–41
Ducrey NM, Glauser MP, Frei PC (1980) Corneal transplantation: ABO blood groups and HLA compatibility. Ann Ophthalmol 7:880–884
Foulks GN, Sanfilippo F (1982) Beneficial effects of histocompatibility in high-risk corneal transplantation. Am J Ophthalmol 94:622–629
Gore SM, Vail A, Bradley BA, Rogers CA, Easty DL, Armitage WJ (1995) HLA-DR matching in corneal transplantation. Systematic review of published evidence. Corneal Transplant Follow-up Study Collaborators. Transplantation 60:1033–1039
Hill JC, Creemers PC (1997) An adverse matching effect for the HLA-B locus in corneal transplantation. Transplant Int 10:145–149
Hoffmann F (1976) Suture technique for perforating keratoplasty (author's transl). Klin Monatsbl Augenheilkd 169:584–590
Hoffmann F (1994) Topical cyclosporin A in corneal transplantation. In: Zierhut M, Pleyer U, Thiel HJ (eds) Immunology of corneal transplantation. Aeolus Press, Science Publishers, Buren, The Netherlands, pp 253–262
Hoffmann F, Tregel M, Noske W, Bunte S (1994) HLA-B and -DR match reduces the allograft reaction after keratoplasty. Ger J Ophthalmol 3:100–104
Hopkins KA, Maguire MG, Fink NE, Bias WB (1992) Reproducibility of HLA-A, -B, and -DR typing using peripheral blood samples: results of retyping in the collaborative corneal transplantation studies. Collaborative Corneal Transplantation Studies Group (corrected). Hum Immunol 33:122–128
http://www.ctstransplant.org
http://www.efiweb.org/standards.html
Jager MJ (1992) Corneal Langerhans cells and ocular immunology. Reg Immunol 4:186–195
Jones BR (1973) Criteria of a diagnosis of a corneal allograft rejection. In: Corneal graft failure. Ciba Foundation Symposium 15. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 340–347
Li Q, He Y (1993) An immunohistochemical study of Langerhans cells, T-cells and the HLA antigen in human cornea. Yan Ke Xue Bao 9:121–125
Morita N, Munkhbat B, Gansuvd B, Kanai N, Hagihara M, Shimazaki J, Tsubota K, Tsuji K (1998) Effect of HLA-A and -DPB1 matching in corneal transplantation. Transplant Proc 30:3491–3492
Munkhbat B, Hagihara M, Sato T, Tsuchida F, Sato K, Shimazaki J, Tsubota K, Tsuji K (1997) Association between HLA-DPB1 matching and 1-year rejection-free graft survival in high-risk corneal transplantation. Transplantation 63:1011–1016
Munkhbat B, Hagihara M, Sato T, Tsuchida F, Shimazaki J, Tsubota K, Tsuji K (1996) HLA class II DNA typing using ocular tissue and its usefulness in corneal transplantation. Transplant Proc 28:1257–1258
Munkhbat B, Hagihara M, Shimazaki J, Kanai N, Morita N, Gansuvd B, Kato S, Tsubota K, Tsuji K (1999) The impact of HLA-A matching in corneal transplantation. Tokai J Exp Clin Med 24:63–71
Mytilineos J, Scherer S, Hansen B, Gaweco A, Opelz G (1990) RFLP-DR beta and serological HLA-DR typing of 200 kidney recipients and 1,000 controls. Transplant Proc 22:1911–1912
Nishimura JK, Hodge DO, Bourne WM (1999) Initial endothelial cell density and chronic endothelial cell loss rate in corneal transplants with late endothelial failure. Ophthalmology 106:1962–1965
Opelz G, Scherer S, Mytilineos J (1997) Analysis of HLA-DR split-specificity matching in cadaver kidney transplantation: a report of the Collaborative Transplant Study. Transplantation 63:57–59
Parham P (1991) Bone marrow transplantation. Making just the right match. Nature 350:111–113
Pels E, Schuchard Y (1983) Organ-culture preservation of human corneas. Doc Ophthalmol 56:147–153
Pels E, van der Gaag R (1984) HLA-A, B, C and HLA-DR antigens and dendritic cells in fresh and organ culture preserved corneas. Cornea 3:231–239
Pepose JS, Gardner KM, Nestor MS, Foos RY, Pettit TH (1985) Detection of HLA class I and II antigens in rejected human corneal allografts. Ophthalmology 92:1480–1484
Roelen DL, van Beelen E, van Bree SP, van Rood JJ, Volker-Dieben HJ, Claas FH (1995) The presence of activated donor HLA class I-reactive T lymphocytes is associated with rejection of corneal grafts. Transplantation 59:1039–1042
Roy R, Des Marchais B, Bazin R, Boisjoly HM, Dube I, Laughrea PA (1997) Role of ABO and Lewis blood group antigens in donor-recipient compatibility of corneal transplantation rejection. Ophthalmology 104:508–512
Sanfilippo F, MacQueen JM, Vaughn WK, Foulks GN (1986) Reduced graft rejection with good HLA-A and B matching in high-risk corneal transplantation. N Engl J Med 315:29–35
Terasaki PI, McCurdy B, McClelland J (1973) Microdroplet lymphocyte cytotoxicity test. Nippon Rinsho 31:3314–3320
Vail A, Gore SM, Bradley BA, Easty DL, Rogers CA (1994) Corneal graft survival and visual outcome. A multicenter Study. Corneal Transplant Follow-up Study Collaborators. Ophthalmology 101:120–127
Vail A, Gore SM, Bradley BA, Easty DL, Rogers CA, Armitage WJ (1994) Influence of donor and histocompatibility factors on corneal graft outcome. Transplantation 58:1210–1216
Vail A, Gore SM, Bradley BA, Easty DL, Rogers CA, Armitage WJ (1997) Conclusions of the corneal transplant follow-up study. Collaborating Surgeons. Br J Ophthalmol 81:631–636
Volker-Dieben HJ, Claas FH, Schreuder GM, Schipper RF, Pels E, Persijn GG, Smits J, D'Amaro J (2000) Beneficial effect of HLA-DR matching on the survival of corneal allografts. Transplantation 70:640–648
Williams KA, Muehlberg SM, Lewis RF (1997) The Australian corneal graft registry 1996 report. Adelaide, Australia
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to Ulrike Geidner, Suzanne Hoppe, Baerbel Kirschbaum and Nora Wendt for expert technical assistance.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This work was presented in part at the 100th meeting of the German Society of Ophthalmology, Berlin, 26–29 September 2002
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Khaireddin, R., Wachtlin, J., Hopfenmüller, W. et al. HLA-A, HLA-B and HLA-DR matching reduces the rate of corneal allograft rejection. Graefe's Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 241, 1020–1028 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00417-003-0759-9
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00417-003-0759-9